Life With Brian
Life With Brian - Community Benefits?
14th Dec 11
I have just had a great idea to raise money for groups in my local community.
I will create an attractive, welcoming venue and invite all the economically vulnerable people I can find to come along. I will especially seek out people who could really do with a lift in their financial situation, people who aspire to a better way of life but know they just can’t get there on their current income, people who are struggling to make ends meet. I’ll also invite the lonely and socially isolated, everyone who need somewhere they can have some human contact.
When they get there I will give them the opportunity of a lifetime. Every half hour they can each give me, say $50. I will usually give $45 back to them, but just occasionally and in a completely random way I will give someone substantially more, let’s say $500,000.
Just think what a lift everyone will receive from the hope of getting the $500,000! What a difference it would make to their lives. And what fun they will have in the meantime handing over their money and not knowing whether they would get 90% back or a big win. They can carry on for as long as they like, or at least until they run out of money.
Of course I could not give away the $500,000 very often. I would need to cover the cost from the hourly payments I receive from participants. Then there are the necessary overheads. I want to make the venue attractive and comfortable and maybe provide cheap food as an additional attraction. A liquor license would help too of course. As I am expecting a lot of people will be attracted to my little game I shall need space for a big car park and I shall have to employ plenty of staff.
Remember I am not doing this for myself, I am doing it for my community so I will need to make enough to fund some local community groups. Charities and sporting groups would be a good option as they will give my venture a very positive public profile. Naturally I would also have to pay myself as the CEO of the enterprise. I wonder what the going rate would be for such a venture?
I think this will catch on and it will have so many benefits. It will give people hope of striking it lucky and escaping the struggle of poverty. It will create employment. It will support community groups. Why I might even be able to fund my local NRL team, they always seem to be stuck for a dollar.
Mind you I do worry that any local, state or federal government worth a vote will find it just too exploitative of vulnerable people to permit it in their jurisdiction.
What’s that you say? Someone is already doing it? And they have devised machines to take the money?
Comments on this article
Hi Brian,
I enjoyed your witty article. But the issues remain important, and for me personally raises an ethical question about accepting CDSE grants. There is a counter-argument that, as my organisation accepts a Community Services grant from the NSW Government, and the NSW Government raises money from all sorts of disparate sources (including funds from gambling), we are already in receipt of funds raised from gambling and therefore what's the point in making an ethical stance about CDSE grants. And then there is the argument that at least the CDSE grants we do receive are directed to the benefit of our community. Nonetheless, I wouldn't mind a course in ethics for this one....
Perhaps a topic for the next LCSA conference? A 'hypothetical' with Simon Longstaff from the St James Ethic Centre?
Peta Williams, Lower Mountains Neighbourhood Centre
PS An interesting article on this matter in last Saturday's Sydney Morning Herald... those community organisations who support Clubs NSW and those who don't....
You are right to raise the ethical issue, Peta, but I do not believe that small community organisations which accomplish amazing things on limited resources should have to bear the brunt of the heart searching on this one. In next week's blog I shall examine the way the whole community, including every level of government needs to engage the issues created by poker machine pathology.